The night the drain cleaner didn't kill fast enough
A robbery at a hi-fi shop half a mile from here became a torture and a triple murder in 1974.
Last reviewed 20 September 2026 · A three-minute read · 1841–1974
The short answer
Helms Apartments, at 2248-2250 Jefferson Avenue in Ogden, Utah, stands a short walk from the Hi-Fi Shop where five hostages were forced to drink drain cleaner during a robbery on April 22, 1974, killing three of them. The brick building itself was built between 1916 and 1919 by contractor Charles J. Humphris.
The Ogden Utah Tabernacle, a religious building in Ogden , Utah , United States . — 2008 · Ntsimp · Public domain
April 22, 1974
Five hostages were made to drink drain cleaner and three died
Just before closing time, several men walked into the Hi-Fi Shop at 2323 Washington Boulevard and started taking hostages. Two employees were there when it began: Stanley Walker, 20, and Sherry Michelle Ansley, 18. The gunmen marched them down to the basement and tied them up.
The robbery dragged on. A 16-year-old named Cortney Naisbitt wandered in to thank Walker for a parking favor earlier that day. He was pulled into the basement too. Then Walker's father, Orren Walker, 43, came looking for his son and was taken hostage himself. Cortney's mother arrived next, searching for her boy. By the end of the night, five people were tied up in that basement.
The men forced their captors to drink liquid drain cleaner, hoping it would poison them without noise or mess. It burned their mouths and throats instead of killing them outright. One victim was kicked with a pen driven into his ear. An 18-year-old hostage was raped. Then three of the five were shot.
Police could only build a case against three men, all enlisted airmen from Hill Air Force Base: Dale Selby Pierre, William Andrews, and Keith Roberts. Pierre and Andrews were convicted of murder and sentenced to death. Both were later executed. Roberts, who had waited outside in a getaway van, was convicted only of robbery. The other men involved were never caught.
The gunmen believed drain cleaner would kill their hostages quietly. It didn't.
1912
A Danish novelist collapsed and died mid-lecture-tour in Ogden
Ogden could turn even a scheduled stop into an ending. The Danish novelist Herman Bang came through the city in 1912 on an American lecture tour. It was one town among many on his itinerary. He never left it. Bang collapsed and died in Ogden mid-tour. He was known across Denmark for his impressionistic novels. He died in a city he was only passing through. Nothing on his schedule that week suggested the trip would end here.
1916 to 1919
A contractor built one of Ogden's smallest, most striking apartments
Ninety feet from where you stand, an Ogden contractor named Charles J. Humphris put up a modest brick apartment building between 1916 and 1919. The Helms Apartments rise two and a half stories. Two units sit on each of three floors. Historians later called it one of the smallest and most visually interesting of Ogden's pre-Depression apartment buildings. It still stands at 2248-2250 Jefferson Avenue. A passerby would see nothing remarkable. The brick face gives no hint of anything more than ordinary housing. That is exactly what makes Ogden's ordinary buildings worth a second look.
1969 to 1972
Downtown storefronts gave way to a temple's single spire
Half a mile away, the church chose a different kind of transformation. In 1969 the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints broke ground on the Ogden Utah Temple. The church had held the 10-acre lot since Ogden was first settled. The site sat in the middle of downtown. It was boxed in by ordinary shops and offices. Church president Joseph Fielding Smith dedicated the finished temple in January 1972. The dedication took three days. Its modern single-spire design broke sharply from the businesses around it. A stretch of everyday storefronts had become sacred ground almost overnight.
1928 to now
A small house on 22nd Street changed hands quietly
The lot under your feet has its own quieter record. At 619 22nd Street, Weber County's assessor lists a house built in 1928. It is eight hundred square feet on a tenth of an acre. It has passed through private hands since then. These small residential sales leave no headline behind them. They leave only a deed and a date. No fire, no trial, nothing the county thought worth flagging beyond the year it went up.
The basement on Washington Boulevard is gone, but the street grid that led five people into it still runs the same course through town.
Open this place in Strata
Every person, building and event in this story opens into its own dig in the app — and it will dig the ground you are standing on instead, wherever that is.
Sourced records, high and medium confidence. Era background is marked as such.
Modern
from 1841
A little over half a kilometer away, Ogden's municipal cemetery has been receiving burials since 1841, three years before the city itself was formally organized.
About three-quarters of a kilometer away, this church went up in 1875, one of the older surviving buildings in Ogden, and joined the National Register in 1973.
At 2248-2250 Jefferson Avenue, this two-and-a-half-story brick building was called one of the smallest but most visually interesting pre-Depression apartment buildings in the city, and was listed on the National Register in 1987.
Built to house the Forest Service's Intermountain Region offices, this federal building went up during 1933 and 1934 and joined the National Register in 2006.
The Weber Stake Tabernacle stood for over a century before it was torn down in 1971 to make way for the Ogden Utah Temple, dedicated a short walk to the west.
At the Hi-Fi Shop across town, men held five hostages and forced them to drink corrosive drain cleaner during a robbery on April 22, 1974, killing three of them.
Men robbed the Hi-Fi Shop at 2323 Washington Boulevard on April 22, 1974, took five hostages into the basement, forced them to drink liquid drain cleaner, and shot three of them. Dale Selby Pierre and William Andrews were convicted of murder and later executed; Keith Roberts was convicted only of robbery.
What was here before the Helms Apartments were built?
The material does not describe what stood on the site before Charles J. Humphris put up the Helms Apartments between 1916 and 1919.
Who built the Helms Apartments?
Ogden contractor Charles J. Humphris built the Helms Apartments between 1916 and 1919, a two-and-a-half-story brick building with two units on each of three floors.
Why is the Ogden Utah Temple significant?
The Ogden Utah Temple was built starting in 1969 on land the church had held since Ogden's earliest settlement, and was dedicated by church president Joseph Fielding Smith in January 1972 over three days, replacing a stretch of downtown storefronts.
Who was Herman Bang and why does he connect to Ogden?
Herman Bang was a Danish novelist on an American lecture tour in 1912 who collapsed and died in Ogden, a city that was only meant to be one stop on his itinerary.